Both the crankshaft and Camshaft are essential to internal combustion engines, they serve distinct functions—crankshafts convert reciprocating motion to rotational motion, and camshafts control valve timing.
Here’s a detailed comparison between crankshaft and camshaft, focusing on their function, design, operation, and manufacturing:
In this article :
1. Function
Crankshaft:
The primary function of the crankshaft is to convert the reciprocating motion of the pistons into rotational motion. This rotation is ultimately used to drive the vehicle’s wheels through the transmission system.
Also Read : What is a crankshaft?
Camshaft:
The camshaft’s role is to control the timing of the intake and exhaust valves. It opens and closes the valves at the correct time to ensure optimal air-fuel intake and exhaust gas expulsion during the engine’s cycles.
Also Read : What is a camshaft?
2. Location in the Engine
Crankshaft:
It is located at the bottom of the engine, inside the engine block, and is mounted within main bearings.
Camshaft:
The camshaft may be positioned in the engine block (in pushrod engines) or in the cylinder head (in overhead camshaft engines like SOHC or DOHC).
3. Design and Structure
Crankshaft:
The crankshaft is a complex and heavy component with crankpins, main journals, counterweights, and oil passages. It must be precisely balanced to handle large dynamic forces.
Camshaft:
The camshaft is simpler in design, with multiple cam lobes along its shaft. These lobes press on valve lifters or rocker arms to actuate the valves.
4. Speed of Rotation
Crankshaft:
It rotates at full engine speed (RPM) since it is directly connected to the pistons and power stroke.
Camshaft:
It rotates at half the speed of the crankshaft in a four-stroke engine, because each valve opens once every two crankshaft revolutions.
5. Type of Movement
Crankshaft:
It experiences rotational movement driven by the vertical movement of the pistons during combustion.
Camshaft:
It also rotates, but its movement is used to push valve components vertically, operating valves at specific engine phases.
6. Drive Mechanism
Crankshaft:
It is driven by the pistons through combustion and initiates the motion in the engine.
Camshaft:
It is driven by the crankshaft via a timing belt, chain, or gear to ensure synchronized valve operation.
7. Material and Manufacturing
Crankshaft:
Manufactured from forged steel, cast iron, or billet steel for high durability. The process involves forging/casting, rough and precision machining, heat treatment, and balancing.
Camshaft:
Made from cast iron, forged steel, or billet steel. It requires precise cam lobe machining and surface hardening to withstand wear and maintain timing accuracy.
Also Read : Camshaft and crankshaft manufacturing in detail.
8. Stress and Wear
Crankshaft:
It bears high loads and torsional forces, especially during combustion. Proper lubrication and balancing are essential to prevent failure.
Camshaft:
Although it experiences less mechanical stress, the cam lobes face high wear due to constant contact with valve lifters or followers.
9. Maintenance and Symptoms of Failure
Crankshaft:
Symptoms of crankshaft issues include engine knocking, vibration, low oil pressure, or even total engine failure if a journal is damaged.
Camshaft:
Common signs of camshaft wear or failure include poor engine performance, misfires, ticking noises, and irregular valve timing.
10. Cost and Complexity
Crankshaft:
More expensive and complex due to its size, weight, and the need for precise balancing and strength.
Camshaft:
Generally less costly but requires extremely accurate profiling of the lobes to ensure proper valve timing.
Conclusion
The crankshaft and camshaft are both essential components in an internal combustion engine, each playing a unique and critical role. The crankshaft handles power delivery and rotational motion, while the camshaft ensures precise valve operation. Their differences in design, function, and mechanical demands reflect the distinct roles they play in the engine’s performance and efficiency.
Other courses:
