The terms IC engine and EC engine refer to two fundamentally different types of engines based on how they generate power. Let’s break down the detailed differences between the Internal Combustion (IC) Engine and the External Combustion (EC) Engine:
In this article:
1. Definition
- IC Engine (Internal Combustion Engine):
- The combustion of fuel occurs inside the engine cylinder.
- Example: Petrol and diesel engines used in cars, bikes.
- EC Engine (External Combustion Engine):
- The combustion of fuel takes place outside the engine.
- Heat generated is transferred to a working fluid (like steam), which then performs work.
- Example: Steam engines, steam turbines.
Also Read: Internal Combustion Engine in Detail.
2. Working Fluid
- IC Engine:
- Fuel and air mixture is the working fluid, directly combusted in the cylinder.
- EC Engine:
- Uses a separate working fluid like steam, heated by an external source (coal, gas, nuclear).
3. Fuel Combustion Location
- IC Engine:
- Inside the engine.
- EC Engine:
- In a separate combustion chamber or furnace.
4. Applications
- IC Engine:
- Automobiles, motorcycles, aircraft, small generators.
- EC Engine:
- Power plants (steam turbines), old locomotives, industrial heating systems.
5. Efficiency
- IC Engine:
- Generally higher thermal efficiency due to direct combustion.
- EC Engine:
- Less efficient due to heat transfer losses.
6. Cooling and Heat Loss
- IC Engine:
- Requires air or liquid cooling (radiator systems).
- EC Engine:
- Easier to manage heat since combustion is external.
7. Pollution and Emissions
- IC Engine:
- More localized pollution (CO, NOx, unburnt hydrocarbons).
- EC Engine:
- Better control over emissions since combustion is external and more regulated.
8. Maintenance
- IC Engine:
- More wear and tear due to high-pressure internal combustion; requires frequent servicing.
- EC Engine:
- Less mechanical stress; typically longer-lasting with lower maintenance in steady conditions.
9. Load Handling
- IC Engine:
- Better for varying loads, fast response (ideal for vehicles).
- EC Engine:
- Suitable for steady load applications (power generation).
10. Size and Portability
- IC Engine:
- Compact, portable — suitable for mobile applications.
- EC Engine:
- Bulky and stationary due to boiler and furnace size.
Summary Table
| Feature | IC Engine | EC Engine |
|---|---|---|
| Combustion Location | Inside the engine | Outside the engine |
| Working Fluid | Air + fuel | Steam or other external medium |
| Applications | Vehicles, generators | Power plants, steam engines |
| Efficiency | Higher (direct combustion) | Lower (heat transfer losses) |
| Maintenance | Frequent | Less frequent |
| Portability | Portable | Stationary |
| Pollution Control | Harder | Easier |
Watch the difference between IC and EC Engine on Youtube.
Other courses:
